Showing posts with label sunscreen labelling. Show all posts
Showing posts with label sunscreen labelling. Show all posts

Thursday, 27 August 2015

Why Current Sunscreens Are Failing the Public

Sunscreens have been in the news lately. I thought that it would be timely to focus this blog on the issues. The EWG has named Neutrogena as the number # 1  sunscreen brand to avoid in their 2015 annual “Hall of Shame” report. It has gone viral. However many other leading brands continue to use the soluble filters that attain tissue levels and are implicated as hormone disruptors and carcinogens. 

These filters include :

  • oxybenzone, avobenzone, homosalate, octisalate, octocrylene, 4-methyl benzilidene camphor and regular octinoxate. 
Better and safer particle based insoluble filters include :
  • zinc oxide, encapsulated octinoxate,  titanium dioxide, and Tinosorb S and Tinosorb M (still awaiting FDA and Health Canada approval)


Here is an excerpt from the EWG report naming Neutrogena as the number 1 sunscreen to avoid:

“The Environmental Working Group (EWG) has released their 2015 guide to sunscreen, and among the worst brands for sun protection is the number one culprit for toxicity and false advertising, Neutrogena.“Neutrogena’s advertising hype is further from reality than any other major brand we studied. It claims to be the “#1 dermatologist recommended suncare brand, yet all four products highlighted on Neutrogena’s suncare web page rate 7, in the red – worst – zone in our database,” says EWG.  Not only do many Neutrogena sunscreens contain harmful chemicals like oxybenzone and methylisothiazolinone –– but their advertised SPF levels of over 70 have been debunked by the U.S. Food and Drug Administration. According to the federal department, SPF levels max out at about 50. Europe, Australia and Japan have already banned brands from advertising SPF levels over 50. EWG states 80 per cent of Neutrogena sunscreens contain oxybenzone, “a hormone-disrupting sunscreen filter” and 33 per cent contain retinyl palmitate, “a form of vitamin A linked to skin damage”. 

Taking it a Step Further:

What the document does not say is that the entire class of soluble filters – benzophenone, homosalate and others likely have the same effects and that all the leading brands that use these filters are equally harmful. This would include most Johnson and Johnson, L’Oreal, Coppertone, Proctor and Gamble, Banana Boat products, and 85 % of available sunscreens (EWG Hall of Shame 2015). The same filters give UVB biased protection and do not prevent cancer and photoaging. They are likely a factor in rising skin cancer rates. There are a growing list of adverse effects like reproductive problems, autism spectrum disorders and ADHD linked to hormone disruptors that must include soluble sunscreen filters – oxybenzone, avobenzone, homosalate, octisalate, octocrylene and others.  Each person should make their own choice between two classes of sunscreens.  Either choose sunscreens with small molecular weight soluble filters that obtain tissue levels, give incomplete or UVB-biased protection  to prevent sunburn but little protection against skin cancer and photoaging, and probably have harmful effects due to hormone disruption and carcinogenic effects. The alternative is to choose a balanced sunscreen with insoluble particle type filters that remain on the skin,  give you balanced UVB/UVA or better protection, and have no possible adverse effects.

A Word on Recent Controversy:

CBS news just reported a Consumers Report from May 2015 that 11/34 sunscreens failed to achieve their SPF claims at only 16-70% of their labelled value. This mirrors another report from a consumer group in the UK reported on the BBC website that only 1 in 5 consumers in Britain understand that the SPF only predicts UVB or sunburn protection and are aware of  or understand that the Boots-Diffey star system of 1-5 stars is an index of UVA protection and the balance or ratio of UVA/UVB protection. The BBC also reported in May a consumer group testing of Boots and Hawaiian Tropic sunscreens in the UK, showed the majority did not meet their SPF claims. You do not need studies to prove this – just ask most fair-skinned consumers on holiday – most end up with a sunburn despite using the typical brand names and re-applying them every 2-3 hours as instructed. 

SPF values are manipulated by adding anti-inflammatory agents that do not extinct any UV radiation but decrease the redness on skin and mask the biologic marker and first warning signal for injury to the skin. The solar lamps in labs have a sharp fall at 370 nm and a cut-off of 400nm- unlike sunlight where the curve continues to rise. Studies measuring SPF in actual sunlight show that even high SPF sunscreens at 30-100 usually only attain 10-20% of their labelled SPF claims. It was reported at the Annual Photomedicine Meeting in San Francisco this year that as an example Neutrogena Ultra-Sheer SPF 65 had a SPF value of only 10 in sunlight. The MED responses were assessed by luminary dermatologists not a lab technician!

Ways Forward:

We have always said that using SPF, UVA-PF, and CW values to establish the level of protection is the regulatory hurdle to assure adequate sun protection- an SPF of 30-50, a UVA-PF of a minimum 10 for SPF 30 and a minimum of 17 for SPF to meet or exceed the EU criteria of a UVA-PF/SPF ratio >1/3, and a CW of >370 nm as the secondary measure of balanced protection. This should be expressed on a label as a global standard in a very easy and transparent system to understand for sun protection- minimal, medium, high, and very high.

We advocate that sunscreens be UVA dominant with the ratio as close to 1 as possible, given the new studies over the past 10 years that prove UVA is the main factor in cancer and aging. UVB produces superficial injury as a shorter wavelength and lower intensity- it initiates sunburn and the DNA damage cycle, and modulates the process. UVA1 produces deeper DNA injury in the dermis, produces local and systemic inhibition of the immune system, and completes the damage cycle for photoaging and cancer. The majority of mutations in the keratotic basal layer where most cancers arise are UVA fingerprint mutations (not UVB as previously assumed), from hallmark studies over the past decade. UVA does not vary with latitude, or time of day, is present on cloudy days, is 15 X more intense than UVB, penetrates car and window glass, and is a deeper penetrating longer wavelength. It is easier to decrease your UVB exposure than to hide from UVA. Over 40 years it was counter-intuitive for dermatologists to believe that UVB was the main culprit in cancer and photoaging. Most still do. 



The entire protection strategy that includes the use of UVB-biased sunscreens has failed as is evident from rising cancer rates. In N. America rising skin cancer rates are due in part to ineffective sunscreens with partial UV or UVB-biased coverage. 5 million NMSC cases in the USA now cost the health care system 8.1 billion (up from I million in 1987). In the UK skin cancer has shown an alarming increase of 40% in the past 4 years. In Canada rates rise at a steady 2-3% per annum and melanoma was the 2nd fastest rising cancer in 2014-15. It is now the leading cause of cancer death in girls aged 15-30 years. Balanced UVA dominant sunscreens could reduce skin cancer rates in 4 decades- NMSC by up to 80% and melanoma by up to 55%.

Final Recommendations: 

Until Tinosorb S and Tinosorb M are approved by the FDA and Health Canada, the only filter or combination of filters in N. America that meet the requirements for safety and balanced protection are as follows:
·       Zinc oxide alone, zinc oxide plus titanium dioxide, or zinc oxide plus encapsulated octinoxate are safe among those available here. Mexoryl SX and LX are also molecules that are > the 500 Dalton rule for no percutaneous entry- both are owned by L’Oreal and are never used without other undesirable filters from the soluble group.
·       Any filter has to used after expert consideration of the absorption curve and transmission metrics, the concentration of each filter, and the proper dispersion of actives within inactive ingredients. The Honest Company (Jessica Alba) fiasco demonstrates this. They had a 20%  ZnO but complaints of poor esthetics were an issue. They reduced the ZnO to 9% - no other active. Anyone with a basic knowledge of Photometrics would know that the true SPF or Real Life SPF in sunlight can only be 12-15 maximum. Each filter based on its UVB/UVA2 absorption efficiency has a finite SPF units per 1% concentration. This only provides minimal UVB or sunburn protection for < 1 hour in the full sun for a very fair-skinned person. If it was dispersed poorly this could fall to around 15 minutes- hence all those sunburns seen on mother-baby blogs. At 9% a second primary and safe UVB filter would be required –either titanium dioxide or encapsulated octinoxate in a concentration of 7.5% to attain a true SPF of around 25-28. Zinc oxide at >15 % with 7.5% of either titanium dioxide or encapsulated octinoxate will reach SPF 30 plus and have adequate UVA protection. 

Chart with Theoretical Maximum SPF Units per 1% of Active

FilterMax. # of SPF Units per 1% of Active
UVB
Octinoxate2.8
Homosalate1.5
Titanium Dioxide2.6
Octisalate1.6
Oxybenzone2.3
Octocrylene2.1
UVA
Avobenzone1.9
Zinc Oxide1.6
Tinosorb M2.2
Tinosorb S3.1

Simply Zinc™ (CyberDERM) with 22% gives the best balanced protection and Every Morning Sun Whip ™ is not far behind. We believe both are the most esthetic zinc oxide sunscreens found anywhere. Consumers love the products knowing they are safe even for pregnancy and give maximal protection. My dermatologist wife needed a sunscreen to actually prevent skin cancer and photoaging, and as a high risk obstetrician, I needed to know filters did not pass into maternal blood and reach the fetus. A safe, effective, and esthetic sunscreen was hard to find, so we made our own.

Finally, at the World Congress in Dermatology, we learned that there may be evidence that the soluble filters are also photocarcinogenic and induce skin cancer in susceptible subjects- another reason for soluble filters to be banned under The Precautionary Principle. Imagine how egregious it is that a product could cause the disease it is supposed to prevent.  However, I am not optimistic that anything will change. Finally, several of the soluble filters – octinoxate, avobenzone and octocrylene can be encapsulated that converts them to larger size, so they behave like insoluble particles and become safe. We use encapsulated octinoxate in one sunscreen. The silica capsule is inert and the molecule now sits on the skin like zinc oxide and attains the same safety profile. Encapsulation increases the size from 0.5 nm to 7 microns- larger by about 14,000 times. Industry inexplicably ignores this technology that would make some of the offending filters safe.       
                                                                            

© Denis K. Dudley MD 2015. All Rights reserved.

Wednesday, 30 April 2014

The Latest Science in Sunscreens and Protection: What You Need To Know

For this third post, I thought I would pass on interesting and relevant scientific news from recent meetings I attended with my wife, Dr. Sharyn Laughlin. The Annual Meeting of the Photomedicine Society and the Annual Meeting of The American Academy of Dermatology were held in March 2014.

More evidence was presented by Dr. Thomas Ruenger for the role of UVA in inducing enzymes that promote the breakdown of collagen and elastin as an important mechanism for photoaging. The findings presented also show that the effect of longwave UVA is the most pronounced and much greater than the effect of UVB. Over the past decade, there has been a volume of evidence from scientific studies that confirm the important effect that UVA has on photoaging and the induction of cellular damage, leading to all forms of skin cancer. This should come as no surprise to anyone – including those who still do not acknowledge the inherent dangers of UVB-biased sunscreens that give unbalanced protection, and allow the effects of UVA to be mostly unabated and cumulative.

Our Skin: A Work of Art Worth Saving
Not everything in science needs a study. Many definitive studies cannot be done in humans for ethical and practical reasons. Sometimes critical thinking, cognitive analysis, deductive reasoning – fancy terms for common sense – is all that is required. UVA penetrates to the deeper dermis where the important elements regulating genetics, immunity, and cell function reside, while UVB barely penetrates through the epidermis. UVA is ubiquitous, essentially the same at any latitude and time of day, and is 15-16 times more potent than the dose of UVB that only accounts for 5% of the UV band. It should be logical that the adverse effects of UV radiation may have more to do with UVA than UVB. Erythema or redness of the skin, the first sign of sunburn, and the eventual sunburn, is commonly believed by many people (even some physicians), to be UVB (290-320 nm) mediated skin damage, with a minor contribution from UVA-2 (320-340 nm). It is the basis of the sun protection factor (SPF) that is a label standard that indicates the degree to which a sunscreen reduces the sunburn reaction. The new labelling rules to be adopted in N. America changes the meaning of SPF to denote sunburn protection factor, a more accurate definition. It should convey to the consumer that SPF is a measure of the sunscreen’s ability to reduce or protect from sunburn but is not an adequate measure of protection to other adverse effects of the sun. The erythema-sunburn reaction and its genesis is actually more complex and is also related to UVA-1 effects.

Anyone who has had a sunburn by not applying a sunscreen on a very cloudy day has experienced a UVA sunburn. It is a deeper burn and much more painful that the usual sunburn that starts with UVB initiation. A sunscreen that completely blocks only UVB will not always prevent sunburn and over time a gradual or delayed sunburn develops to the UVA part of the sun. UVB is more efficient in causing sunburn and produces the immediate redness. UVA accounts for 95% of UV exposure and this higher absolute amount contributes to erythema. The early or mainly UVB initiated sunburn reaction, is a protective response telling you to get out the sun when the damage is early and more superficial. Continued sun exposure, even with a sunscreen of high SPF, but minimal UVA-1 protection, eventually leads to a more severe sunburn and the deeper damage that causes irreversible consequences- photoaging and the DNA changes that may lead to cancer many years down the road. SPF values > 15 can only be attained if the UV filters used are reducing transmission of UVA-2 and UVA-1, but is primarily a measure of UVB attenuation.

Industry consultants continue to push the trend arguing for high SPF sunscreens with values > 50 even approaching 100. There is a minor photometric basis for using a higher SPF. Looking at the transmission, rather than what is blocked does show that SPF 30 gives twice the protection than SPF 15, a SPF 60 twice that of SPF 30 and four times SPF 15. An SPF 15 blocks 93.3% of incident UV compared to 96.6% with SPF 30, a difference of 3.3% for doubling the concentration of filters. However, considering what gets through by counting photons of light shows that only half the amount gets through with the higher SPF. The higher SPF also compensates for the lower application amounts used by consumers in practice than the amount applied for laboratory SPF testing. There is some truth in a consumer thinking that a higher SPF allows you better protection and a SPF 30 allows you to stay out twice as long as a SPF 15. The danger is that the higher SPF will have some UVA protection but not nearly enough, if it does not contain one of the limited number of filters that give adequate UVA-1 protection. I am cynical enough to think that industry pushes high SPF sunscreens knowing that the public assumes they are better in every respect. Given a choice between a SPF 30 and a SPF 50, always select the more balanced sunscreen with better UVA-1 protection. This is easy to do in the UK or Europe. Look for Boots 4 or 5 stars in the UK or a UVA-PF to SPF ratio of > 1/3 in Europe. The more this ratio approaches 1, the better the sunscreen is for affording you balanced and proper protection. North American consumers have no such ability  to use the label metrics for selection. The new rule of using a Critical Wavelength (CW) of 370 nm or greater as proof of truly broad spectrum activity, particularly the most important UVA-1 extinction, will not necessarily be valid.

The CW is a measure of the wavelength at which 90% of the area under the absorption or extinction curve occurs. This relates to broad spectrum activity as to achieve this CW of 370 nm, usually requires a significant UVA absorbance. However, the threshold of 370 nm can be attained by some sunscreens with little overall UVA-PF, particularly in the more problematic UVA-I spectrum approaching 400 nm. Sunscreens with low UVA-PF  and those with moderate UVA-PF can both have the same CW of 370 nm. The shape of the extinction curve is a factor and a UVB biased sunscreen SPF 30, with inadequate or a low UVA-PF  < 10 can attain the same CW of 370 nm as a sunscreen with UVA-PF of ≥ 10. One would fail the EU criteria but both would pass in the USA and Canada, under new regulations being enforced this year. My preference for adequate UVA protection is that SPF 30 values should have a UVA-PF exceeding 20 with the ratio approaching 1. More about these considerations in a later post.


The other important topics discussed at these meetings included the use of anti-inflammatory(AI) agents
cyberderm sunscreen, oral photo-protection
Can a diet rich in anti-oxidants protect you from the sun?
or antioxidants (AO) in sunscreens, and the role for oral photoprotection as a component of a sun protection strategy. The use of AI ingredients will be discussed in detail in a future post. Dr. Salvador Gonzales  reviewed the present status of oral nutrients that afford some measure of UV protection, and its use in oral photoprotection is increasing in Europe at an annual rate of about 5%. He also reminded us that a lifetime UV radiation exposure is attained 1/3 through vacation, compared to 2/3 from every day or non-vacational time. This supports our view that a balanced sunscreen is for daily use all year round. In addition 70-80% of sunburns occur can occur in your backyard. Dr. Mary Matsui presented evidence that certain nutrient and botanical ingredients applied on the skin are a source of non-sunscreen photoprotection. The list of useful agents for oral or topical photoprotection is extensive. Some of these and other agents also may reduce skin damage from visible light (400-770 nm) and near infrared (IRA at 770 -1400 nm), now shown to be relevant in addition to UV in the genesis of adverse effects from sunlight. This an area I am presently researching at CyberDERM. While developing a balanced sunscreen that mimics the UV protection afforded by black clothing or shade, we are identifying the single best antioxidant to add to the formula. Some of the effects of UV and IRA on inducing immune suppression may also be reduced by oral therapy. Longer wavelengths UVA-1 near 400 nm and visible through IRA at 400- 1400 nm, tend to produce deeper damage to the dermis. Oral antioxidants may be more rational and efficient than topical application. The concept of skin therapy from within via the dermal blood vessels is not new. I recall an ad-campaign from many years ago- “have you taken your skin care today”? For therapy to cell damage in the dermis, ingestion and delivery by the dermal blood supply seems more logical than topical administration, which requires absorption through the epidermis, and the agent is not always sure to reach the deep dermis. We are also working on an antioxidant mix for oral supplementation that best achieves all the objectives. For now it appears that taking 2 Gms. of Vitamin C and 1200 IU of Vitamin C increases the minimal erythema dose –  the visible sign of sun damage – by 20% after 1 week and 40% at 3 months (Gonzales et al). Flavonoids and the subgroups- anthocyandins, catechins, flavonols, and isoflavones – all play important roles in modulating and inhibiting the various adverse effects. A diet rich in blue and red berries, red or purple grapes, 1-2 glasses of red wine/day, dark chocolate, green and white teas, apples, broccoli, onions and scallions, kale, soybeans, hot peppers, apricots and celery, provides Flavonoids. This diet with Vitamin C and E as described above may be a useful adjunctive measure to using a balanced sunscreen and sun avoidance  for those at greater risk of cancer and photodamage. These nutrients, along with ingesting curcumin, resveratrol, and pomegranate, are already recommended for a myriad of health benefits. Skin cancer is considered an occupational disease in some provinces of Germany, and in Canada we need a National Occupational Strategy for those involved in outdoor work. For these workers and anyone at higher risk for skin cancer, a dietary approach as outlined is a complementary and responsible self- help initiative.